Saturday, August 11, 2012

Which vert are you?

I contemplate human behavior a lot, including my own. After reading "Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking" I realized that this contemplative trait makes me an introvert. The book also provoked more contemplating, which I find interesting -- a book about introverts making me more introverted.

Anyway, it relates to my travels in 2 ways:

1. Traveling involves talking to strangers and moving out of your comfort zone. This can involve a lot of stress for an introvert.

2. The book pointed to the United States as the most extroverted country in the world, which I get. The author mentioned Europe as a sort of conglomerate. And she talked about introverts in Chinese communities in California, which I suppose was her representation of Eastern countries. Let's just say her cross-cultural analysis was not particularly awesome. I understand, after all, because you can't load your book with research (if it even exists) from every corner of the world. But it still left me with want to mull over what I see here in Spain. And maybe get some feedback!

The United States has an extroverted reputation because of its focus on speaking your mind, taking charge, and getting ahead -- that's in social circles, work environments, and educational expectations. However, I feel that we also harbor some pretty firm, albeit unwritten, rules regarding personal space. I find that people in Spain don't hesitate at all in approaching a friend, keeping their face very close when speaking to them, or touching them in a friendly way. The same behavior would be considered sort of invasive back home. 

Americans also have a custom of being unnecessarily polite. Not saying that people in Spain are rude, they're just honest. When friends here offer to buy me a beer, I used to say no at first: "No, no, I'll get one! Let me buy YOU a beer!" But they were always very persistent, and often won. Some even confronted me about trying to be polite. So I've learned just to say yes. Because they aren't offering me a beer out of politeness, they just want to buy me a beer. In the same way, people here are not hesitant to tell you if you're getting fat, if they don't like the food, or they despise the music. Not to be rude, just to be honest. On the other hand, the U.S. loves their white lies because they prevent potential conflict.

This brings me to a point that the author of "Quiet" was trying to make. She cited the following statistic a few times: studies show that 1 out of every 2 or 3 people is an introvert. So, while a country like the U.S. may highly value extroverts in many aspects of life, anywhere from 33% to 50% of us are introverted. In other words, we're pushing to raise children and young adults with spunk and pizazz, but some of us just don't have it in our genes. Perhaps our reputation doesn't really speak the truth.

I imagine this statistic can roughly be applied to the Spanish population as well. But I'll still echo that social customs here in Spain are particularly extroverted. So I'm not sure these labels mean the same universally.

Of course, another point that the author makes is that none of us are purely bred introverts or extroverts. We've all got a bit of both, some more than others. (Believe it or not, there is such a thing as an ambivert.) So my love for travel and seeing new places, despite also having a love for Saturday nights at home, makes sense.

Overall, the book was very enlightening, and relates to so many people: employers, employees, parents, teachers, lawyers, etc. (In other words, anybody who comes into contact with introverts, or is one.)

I mentioned feedback at the beginning of the post, and I mean it. Let me know what you think, what experiences you've had as an introvert or extrovert.

3 comments:

  1. like i said, i thought Quiet was great, it has really shaped my thinking for meetings for work things, and friend things since i read it. additionally, i really enjoyed the parts about "highly sensitives", i had no idea that that was a real aspect of personality, officially described. totally explained a lot to me...

    my two thoughts about america as a nation of introverts vs. our interactions with people.

    i think some of this can be further explained by the fact that we are becoming increasingly less social as a whole- choosing to not spend time with people. granted, this book came out a while ago now, but see: http://bowlingalone.com/ i dont' think much has changed (aside from maybe people's perceptions that they are actually part of something socially when involved in the internet...) since this book came out.

    the other thought about this all that i have is the concept from quiet, discussing our need for quiet time to complete thoughts, continue thinking about things, process information, but we are constantly being told that "busy" is the only way to be successful (see: http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/06/30/the-busy-trap/?ref=opinion) i think this also adds to the idea that we don't have time for socializing (vs. networking where we "gain" connections for work), because what do we gain from it (obviously not my believe, just an overall sense that successful people have, in my opinion). so we don't do things like have drinks with friends, spend time with our families bc we are feeling pulled into completing productive tasks. our extroversion is simply used towards work, not cultivating community and connections in our non-work lives.

    i read quiet and then had to go to a conference for work, where i was "up" all day long. i wanted nothing more than to come back to my hotel, go swimming alone, and chill on my porch. a hard concept to explain (even to librarians) who want you to go out in large groups with them...
    i did encourage two people who are close to me to read quiet, with good results :)
    i've rambled enough.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your comment, Amy! Your point about using our extroversion only in our work environments is a really good one. Socially, I don't think Americans are particularly extroverted in branching out. Of course, everyone here in Pamplona tells me that natives are very closed-off and in some cases resistant to accepting new people. While, I've found several exceptions, perhaps there are pockets in the world that aren't very good at developing community. Also, people here tell me how impressed they are at Americans' ability to initiate projects themselves (litter cleanup, fundraisers, DIY stuff) instead of waiting for a state institution to do so, as if the socialist structure here prevents people from seeing their own influence on their environment. Now that you make me think about it, community development isn't something that the author really discussed. It can't be that extroverts are the only ones that propel meaningful connections to sustain a community, can it?

    ReplyDelete
  3. i think introverts just make connections on their own terms, and i would venture to say, introverts are the ones making the more serious connections, i.e. their likelihood to be less interested in acquaintances, etc. i don't know...

    very interesting re: perception of u.s. diy aspects.

    ReplyDelete